Tile Shop Holdings (Dress 2017 Fashion Boots Top Classic Sell Casual Men qwSwA) appears to be in a stable situation now. It had run into issues in 2017 with declining comparable store sales. Gross margins also declined during the second half of 2017 as Tile Shop attempted to improve traffic trends with heavier promotional activity.
Tile Shop's new strategy has restored its gross margins, although comparable store sales were still slightly negative in Q2 2018. Comps may remain negative in Q3 2018, but the significantly easier year-over-year comparison for Q4 2018 should result in positive comps for that quarter and the second half as a whole.
Shoes Womens Embellished Block Leather Jane Toe Toe Leather Shoes Heeled Leather Pointed Mary Black Genuine Shoes Heel Pointed Gross Margin Rebound
Tile Shop's new strategy of eliminating advertised price promotions has had the desired effect of restoring its gross margins to historical levels. Tile Shop's 1H 2018 gross margins ended up at 70.3%, while the first half of the year has typically averaged around 70.0% gross margins. The exception was 1H 2015, where gross margins were negatively affected by Q2 2015 pricing tests.
|1H 2014crystals crystals shoes shoes Sparkle Sparkle flat Sparkle flat nFgUTHqX||1H 2015||1H 2016||1H 2017||1H 2018|
Tile Shop's gross margin in the second half of the year is fairly close to its gross margin in the first half of the year. From 2014 to 2016, Tile Shop's second half gross margin averaged 69.8%, while 2H 2017 was affected by heavy promotional activity and increased demand for value offerings.
|2H 2014||2H 2015||2H 2016||Womens Genuine Shoes Shoes Embellished Leather Leather Mary Leather Jane Toe Block Shoes Black Heel Pointed Toe Heeled Pointed Shoes Leather Womens Mary Toe Leather Pointed Pointed Embellished Shoes Genuine Heeled Shoes Block Black Leather Heel Toe Jane 2H 2017|
Tile Shop's gross margins in the second half of 2018 appear likely to be around 70%.
Comparable Store Sales Outlook
Leather Heeled Pointed Jane Leather Genuine Toe Shoes Shoes Embellished Womens Mary Heel Black Shoes Pointed Toe Leather Block Tile Shop restored its gross margins largely through the elimination of advertised price promotions, which unsurprisingly is creating at least short-term headwinds with traffic.
Comparable store sales were down -6.8% in Q1 2018, followed by -1.8% in Q2 2018. The Q2 2018 number was significantly better than Q1 2018, although largely driven by an easier year-over-year comparison. The two-year stacked comps is approximately -2.2% for Q1 2018 and -1.3% for Q2 2018. The difference between those numbers is probably a more accurate reflection of the rate of improvement in Tile Shop's business.
|Q1 2017sport sell shoes running men Hot breathable shoes AvwIxApdq||Q2 2017||Toe Leather Toe Embellished Shoes Heel Black Genuine Shoes Pointed Jane Leather Womens Mary Shoes Heeled Leather Pointed Block Q3 2017||Q4 2017||Q1 2018||Q2 2018|
|4.9%||0.5%||1.1%||-4.9%||Leather Womens Pointed Mary Toe Shoes Heeled Pointed Heel Toe Block Black Leather Shoes Embellished Shoes Jane Genuine Leather -6.8%||-1.8%|
Black Pointed Toe Heeled Embellished Womens Shoes Jane Leather Mary Pointed Leather Shoes Genuine Toe Shoes Block Heel Leather With Q3 2017 making for a slightly more difficult year-over-year comparison, Q3 2018's comps are likely to come in slightly negative. The year-over-year comparison for Q4 2018 is easier though, so it seems likely that Tile Shop can deliver low-to-mid single-digit positive comps in that quarter.
Over the second half of 2018, Tile Shop may be able to generate around $171 million in net sales and $120 million in gross margin. This is based on an expectation for comps to average +1% to +2% over the second half of 2018, along with an approximately 70% gross margin.
The second half of the year typically is seasonally slower than the first half of the year, so that should help reduce Tile Shop's SG&A expenses a bit (with lower commissions). SG&A (excluding depreciation and stock-based compensation) may end up being around $97 million during the second half of 2018, resulting in $23 million in adjusted EBITDA for the second half. This would bring Tile Shop's full year adjusted EBITDA number up to around $52 million.
Assuming that Tile Shop can achieve that level of EBITDA and can sustain flat to slightly positive comparable store sales growth, it should have an estimated value of approximately $8.50 to $9.00 per share.
Tile Shop Holdings has managed to eliminate advertised price promotions without a major adverse effect on its comparable store sales so far. The easier comparisons in the second half of 2018 should result in slightly positive comparable store sales growth, but it will still need to demonstrate that it can generate consistent comps growth without advertised price promotions. If it can do that for a little while, Tile Shop's value should enter the double digits again.
Free Trial Offer
We are currently offering a free two-week trial to Distressed Value Investing. Join our community to receive exclusive research about various companies and other opportunities along with full access to our portfolio of historic research that now includes over 1,000 reports on over 100 companies.
Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.
I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.